Directed and written by Ryan Coogler, Sinners stars Michael B. Jordan in dual roles as twin brothers Smoke and Stack Moore, alongside Hailee Steinfeld, Jack O’Connell, Wunmi Mosaku, Jayme Lawson, and Miles Caton. Set in the deep South during 1932 Mississippi, the film blends Southern Gothic horror with social commentary, set against the backdrop of a Black-owned juke joint built from a reclaimed sawmill. While the cast delivers strong performances across the board, the film’s execution stirs debate — it teases a blood-soaked showdown, but pulls back just when things should explode.

Directed by: Ryan Coogler
Written by: Ryan Coogler

Here comes the spoilers.

The story opens with Smoke and Stack Moore returning home from World War I, hoping to rebuild their lives and offer a safe haven to their community through music, unity, and good bourbon. They set up shop in an old sawmill turned juke joint — an atmospheric location brimming with promise and eerie history. Their cousin Sammie, a gifted musician, draws in crowds from miles around with a voice that seems to summon something beyond the veil. Things take a sharp turn when a group of vampiric strangers led by the unnerving Remmick (played with menace by Jack O’Connell) arrive under cover of darkness, drawn to Sammie’s supernatural talent. The battle lines are drawn between the living, the dead, and something in between.

For nearly a third of the film’s runtime, the sawmill is built up as a symbolic and strategic stronghold. We’re fed breadcrumbs of dread — shadowy figures watching from the trees, cryptic mutterings about blood debts, and stories passed down about the land’s cursed history. So when the inevitable conflict begins to boil, you expect all hell to break loose. But the action never fully ignites. The sawmill’s potential as a battleground — with its splintered wood, sharp blades, and spiritual resonance — is never truly tapped. A few brief bursts of violence appear, but not nearly enough to justify the long build-up. This was supposed to be the set-piece payoff. Instead, it feels like the filmmakers pulled their punches.

That said, the sequence where Sammie sings and spirits of the past and future appear — almost as if time folds in on itself — is nothing short of mesmerizing. It’s visually striking, emotionally heavy, and unlike anything else seen in modern horror. It’s a moment that shows the film’s ambition and creative vision. But this artistic high doesn’t translate into the type of gory, visceral horror fans might expect from a film with such a promising premise. If you’re coming in hoping for a spiritual cousin to From Dusk Till Dawn — full of frenetic pacing and vampiric carnage — you might be left unsatisfied.

Ultimately, Sinners is a film that looks and sounds fantastic, features standout performances, and flirts with greatness. But for all the blood, tension, and lore it promises, it never fully commits to the horror spectacle it could’ve been. It’s a simmering pot of genre ingredients that never quite boils over — bold, haunting, and frustrating all at once.

Thanks for reading Writing Movie ‘WRONGS’.